800-450-6118

Guide to Carpal Tunnel Release Surgery

Dr. Z • Nov 03, 2020

Carpal Tunnel Release Surgery

Surgeons treat carpal tunnel syndrome with a type of hand operation called carpal tunnel release surgery. The "release" refers to the surgeon freeing up the median nerve that's bound or trapped by tissues inside your wrist joint.


Here's what this release surgery is all about. And this is what you can expect during and after the operation.


carpal tunnel sufferer

When to get carpal tunnel release surgery

After arthritis, carpal tunnel syndrome is the most frequent hand problem doctors see. It affects 5 million Americans, with a quarter million new cases each year.


So it's no wonder that carpal tunnel release surgery is also the fourth most common operation performed in the USA. Your surgeon will  recommend release surgery ONLY if you meet the 3 following criteria:

 

  • You've had severe symptoms for at least 6 months. This is important in light of the fact that 50% of patients see their carpal tunnel symptoms resolve on their own. That means numbness, pain, tingling or weakness will simply disappear with no (or very little) help. Usually this occurs within a month of the symptoms first being noticed. But in the other 50% of patients the situation is different. If symptoms last for more than a few months, they'll usually remain if you don't treat them. And in the majority of those sufferers, symptoms will get even more intense over time.
  • The symptoms are so severe they interfere with your life. Within 6-12 months after carpal tunnel symptoms first appear they generally advance to the severe stage. This is when patients report the greatest impact on their lives. For instance, it's almost impossible to get a restful night's sleep. Using your hands on the job or doing simple manual tasks at home is difficult. You fumble, drop things, and simply cannot sustain any hand or finger work for more than a few minutes.

  • You tried every nonsurgical remedy to date. Nonsurgical remedies usually treat carpal tunnel syndrome quite effectively. The main therapies are night bracing, stretching exercises, and myofascial release massage. The vast majority of patients normally see complete relief using these therapies.

 

When your carpal tunnel doctor feels you've met ALL of these 3 criteria, they'll generally recommend carpal tunnel release surgery. 

talk with your doctor

Types of carpal tunnel release surgery

Your doctor will recommend one of two basic types of  carpal tunnel release surgery. These are:


The difference between the two is how the surgeon is able to access the interior of your wrist. Access is necessary because the surgeon must cut the transverse carpal ligament. This structure holds your wrist joint together much like the string of a bow. When the ligament is cut the wrist bones spread apart. 


When that happens, there's more room in between the wrist bones. This then frees up pressure on your median nervr. It effectively "releases” it from being trapped in a tight space. When the nerve is released, symptoms usually disappear (but sometimes the don't - see below).

types of carpal tunnel release surgery

The two types of surgery relate to the two basic ways to cut that ligament. One way ("open" method) is to slice the palm open to expose the ligament. Another way is to insert a thin tube into the wrist ("endoscopic" method) to do the same thing. 


Usually, patients having the "open" technique will have general anesthesia, where you're put to sleep. In contrast, about half of "endoscopic" patients are wide awake during the procedure. But their hand and arm are numbed with an anesthetic "nerve block" injection. 


All surgery has certain dangers and risks. You should know the various pros and cons associated with these two surgery techniques so you can discuss them with your doctor. 

median nerve block

Pros & Cons of OPEN Carpal Tunnel Release Surgery

Pros


  1. Larger incision allows the surgeon to see the whole surgical field without restriction. This lessens the chances of accidentally cutting a nerve or blood vessel, thereby reducing complications.
  2. Requires less surgical skill than the endoscopic technique.
  3. Usually is less costly (important if you're paying out-of-pocket).

Cons 


  1. The larger incision causes more hand trauma, resulting in more postsurgical pain.
  2. A larger incision means more extensive and involved aftercare.
  3. It's usually performed under general anesthesia which some people react to badly.
  4. Since the hand trauma is more extensive, it will require longer hand strength rehabilitation time.
  5. The extensive trauma produces a greater chance of permanent hand weakness. 

Pros & Cons of ENDOSCOPIC Carpal Tunnel Release Surgery

Pros


  1. Smaller incision results in less hand trauma which means less postsurgical pain.
  2. It's usually performed using a local nerve block instead of general anesthesia, reducing possible reaction to anesthesia.
  3. A small incision means faster recovery time and less extensive aftercare.
  4. With less hand trauma, hand strength rehabilitation time is shorter.
  5. Lower chance of permanent hand weakness.

Cons 


  1. Restricts the surgeon's field of view. This increases the potential of accidentally cutting a nerve or blood vessel.
  2. An accidental nicking of a nerve or blood vessel increases the chances of complications like permanent loss of feeling.
  3. Requires more surgical training and skill on the part of the doctor.
  4. Usually is more costly than the open technique.

Details about OPEN carpal tunnel release surgery

This procedure is termed “open” because the surgeon cuts into your palm more broadly. The skin on the palm is spread apart which "opens" the entire area without restricting view of vital structures. This way the surgeon can cut the transverse carpal ligament without danger of accidentally cutting or nicking something else.


Most doctors say the open technique is the safest method. And it's why most surgeons prefer using it.


Open carpal tunnel release surgery can be performed on an outpatient basis. The entire procedure takes 30-45 minutes.


STEP 1

Usually doctors prefer to put the patient under general anesthesia for the open technique. Sometimes the doctor will also inject a numbing agent into the wrist before beginning. Sometimes a median nerve block is used. These will help ease the pain when you wake up. But you will be asleep during the operation.


STEP 2

The nurse or doctor will wrap a tourniquet around your arm. This lessens bleeding as your palm is cut open.


STEP 3

When you're asleep the nurse or surgeon disinfects your hand, wrist, and forearm. Then the doctor makes a 2-3 inch-long incision at the base of your palm. Some surgeons prefer using a "mini-cut". This is about half as long as a standard incision. It helps minimize scar tenderness after the operation. 


STEP 4

With your palm's skin and underlying tissues open, the doctor identifies the ligament and cuts it in half. When it's cut, your wrist bones spread apart, providing more room inside the wrist joint. This relieves pressure on the median nerve.


STEP 5

The doctor closes the incision in your palm with non-resorbable sutures. That means you have to return to the doctor in 7-10 days to remove them. Then the doctor applies several layers of bandages to your hand. 


STEP 6

You are brought out of the anesthesia's induced sleep. Then you're wheeled into the recovery room. You'll stay there 2-4 hours to make sure your vital signs are stable. Then you can go home.

Details about ENDOSCOPIC carpal tunnel release surgery

Endoscopic carpal tunnel release surgery is performed in one of two basic ways:

  • Double portal endoscopic carpal tunnel release surgery
  • Single portal endoscopic carpal tunnel release surgery

Double portal endoscopic carpal tunnel release surgery is the more common of the two surgical techniques (pictured at left). Both have nearly identical surgical STEPS, except for the use of one or two holes in your palm. 


Like the open technique, both procedures are usually performed on an outpatient basis. Both techniques also take about 30 minutes to complete.


STEP 1

With endoscopy, doctors usually prefer using a median nerve block anesthesia. It may or may not be accompanied by a local numbing agent injected directly into your wrist before the surgery starts. All this means you will be wide awake during the surgery. But you won't feel anything.


STEP 2

As with the open technique, for endoscopic carpal tunnel release surgery the nurse or doctor will wrap a tourniquet around your arm. This will lessen any bleeding.


STEP 3

Your hand is disinfected and the surgery begins. In the double portal technique the surgeon makes 2 small holes in your hand. One hole is in your palm and the other is in your wrist. In one hole, the doctor inserts an endoscope, which is a fiberoptic camera. In the other hole, the doctor inserts the scalpel. Then the doctor locates and cuts the ligament. In the single portal technique, both instruments (camera plus scalpel) are inserted through only one hole.


STEP 4

While carefully watching the scalpel with the endoscopic camera, the doctor identifies and precisely cuts the ligament. As with the open technique, your wrist bones then spread apart. This gives your median nerve more room. As a result, the extra room decreases pressure on the median nerve.


STEP 5

The doctor closes one or both small incisions in your palm with non-resorbable sutures. You will return in 7-10 days to have them removed. Smaller bandages are applied over one or both holes. 


STEP 6

Still awake, you're wheeled into the recovery room. You'll remain there for 1-2 hours until your vital signs are stable. Then you can go home.

carpal tunnel surgery scars

Recovering from carpal tunnel release surgery

Time course & effectiveness

Whichever carpal tunnel release surgery technique your doctor chooses, it will take time for you to recover. The outcome of surgery you can expect during your recovery time will fall into one of three categories: 

 

  • Rapid positive results: 31% of patient will have the majority of symptoms disappear immediately. Full recovery may take several months.

  • Delayed positive results: 40% of patients will take many months (up to a year) to see good relief.

  • Surgical Failure: At least  29% of patients will not see a difference in symptoms whatsoever. About half of them will experience even worse symptoms. 
hand therapy

Virtually all patients ask, "If I go through carpal tunnel release surgery, will the results be worth the effort?" To answer, consider the statistics from the National Institutes of Health:

 

  • About 50-70% of patients are satisfied with their surgical results by 2 years. 

  • Another 30-50% are not satisfied by 2 years.

  • Over 90% of surgical patients will have some persistent symptoms ranging from mild to severe. 

  • When symptoms persist, most surgeons advise having another carpal tunnel release surgery. The likelihood of success of such a revision surgery is extremely low (about 21%).

  • Your surgical scar may be tender for up to 1 year. This is especially the case after open carpal tunnel release surgery. 

  • Significant loss of pinch and grip strength are the commonest complaints after surgery. In most cases it recovers, but it usually takes several months. 

 

hand power tool

Other recovery considerations

The recovery period after carpal tunnel release surgery is usually the most difficult portion of the process. It's certainly the most lengthy. For a good outcome, it requires dedication to hand therapy. Those less dedicated can expect poorer outcomes. 

 

  • Over 80% of patients who have carpal tunnel release surgery (no matter the technique used) never return to their occupation. That's because it's likely their job was the cause of the disorder.

  • There are certain risks with carpal tunnel release surgery not common to other surgeries. The incidence of complications is approximately 7%. These include possible nerve damage, permanent weakness, elevated pain, and permanent sensory loss. 

  • Up to 2% of patients may have an infection at the scar. 

  • Up to 11% of patients may have long-lasting or permanent stiffness & pain at the scar site.
     
  • Nearly all patients lose some wrist strength permanently (even with dedicated hand therapy). 

  • Most patients must alter their work responsibilities or change jobs after surgery. 

  • After carpal tunnel release surgery, 30% of patients see  symptoms reappear (called "recurrent symptoms").

 

Factors affecting recovery time after carpal tunnel release surgery

On average, patients take 1-2 months off work after open release surgery. Compare that with 1-2 weeks for endoscopic surgery. Several factors affect the amount of recovery time you need after carpal tunnel release surgery. 


The factors affecting recovery time are different for everybody. Generally speaking, open carpal tunnel release surgery requires more post-surgical therapy and hand rehabilitation than endoscopic surgery. It also requires a greater commitment to hand therapy in order to recover good strength and range of motion. And this may take months or sometimes years.


Usually recovery time takes longer when:


  • You have open carpal tunnel release surgery.
  • Surgery is on your dominant hand. 
  • You smoke.
  • Your occupation demands extensive hand activities.
  • You have poor overall health or you have a chronic condition (e.g., obesity or diabetes).

Conclusion

Your doctor will recommend having one of two kinds of carpal tunnel release surgery. These are the open or endoscopic techniques. The decision about which surgery you'll get is entirely your doctor's. The reason is because the doctor must have experience with one or the other technique. Learn about the differences between these two techniques, including their pros and cons. Then talk with your doctor about which one you'll have. Your postsurgical pain, recovery time, and overall success depends largely on which hand operation you have.

Share by: