From Dr. Z - Carpal tunnel syndrome specialist
Can you tell whether you have carpal tunnel or tendonitis? Actually, tendonitis and carpal tunnel syndrome signs and symptoms are very similar. So you're in the majority if you can't tell the difference.
Sometimes the signs and symptoms of these disorders fool some doctors into making the wrong diagnosis. That's because the two conditions are also similar in how they occur (i.e., repetitive stress).
Most importantly, carpal tunnel syndrome is relatively difficult to treat, especially in its later stages. In contrast, wrist flexor tendonitis is relatively easy to treat - usually with simple rest.
Do you live with hand pain every day? Maybe you have tingling, burning, aching or numbness in your fingers, too. These are all hallmark carpal tunnel syndrome signs. But they can also mean you have wrist flexor tendinitis instead.
Carpal tunnel syndrome is more serious than tendonitis. And it's harder to treat. So knowing how to identify the symptoms of carpal tunnel is the first step in tackling the disorder. Only then can you properly treat it.
Other conditions also have similar signs and symptoms. In fact, de Quervain’s tenosynovitis is often confused as wrist tendonitis. But de Quervain’s tenosynovitis only affects the thumb tendons.
Carpal tunnel syndrome and wrist flexor tendonitis are medically different conditions. But their symptoms can be almost identical. That’s because they share a common factor; they're both caused by tendon inflammation.
Scientists believe that either condition comes from repetitively stressing your hand. That's why these disorders are classified as repetitive stress injuries.
As a result of the stress, tendons inflame and swell. But the similarities between carpal tunnel syndrome, wrist tendonitis, and de Quervain’s tenosynovitis end there.
What distinguishes these conditions is:
It should be noted that every person is different and will experience symptoms and warning signs differently. Also, certain symptoms overlap from one condition to the other.
And YES! You could have both carpal tunnel and tendonitis (and even de Quervain's) simultaneously. So be familiar with their symptoms.
Usually this condition happens when you repetitively stress your hands. But that’s not a rule. Scientists believe that no matter how much you stress your hand, you’re either prone to getting carpal tunnel or you’re not.
However, it’s clear that if you have the tendency to get it, stressing your hand will bring it on. Your daily activities play a big role in your risk of getting carpal tunnel. In fact, there are certain jobs responsible for causing carpal tunnel you should be aware of. The jobs plagued the most by carpal tunnel syndrome are:
You can perform a simple carpal tunnel test on yourself here to determine if you have this condition. It’s highly reliable. In fact, it’s also the very same test hand specialists use in their office to tell if you have carpal tunnel syndrome. The video above demonstrates how they're performed.
Generally, these carpal tunnel syndrome signs and symptoms follow a specific pattern. But they could be different for you compared to somebody else.
Wrist flexor tendonitis is actually a type of repetitive stress injury or RSI. It almost exclusively relates the activities you do with your hands. Often, it’s your job that causes it.
Before thinking about the symptoms of wrist flexor tendonitis, it's best to first examine your occupation. Tendonitis usually affects those who perform repetitive and high velocity, high force hand activities every day for long hours. Those activities (and occupations) are identical to the ones causing carpal tunnel syndrome (listed above).
As already discussed, wrist flexor tendonitis signs and carpal tunnel syndrome signs are very similar. The symptoms are usually in the fingers, hand, wrist or forearm.
Here's good ways to tell
One good way to tell if you have wrist flexor tendonitis is to glide your fingers up and down your forearm tendons (palm side) from wrist to elbow. Unlike carpal tunnel syndrome signs, tendonitis signs will be felt as tender or painful nodes. They're especially prominent directly on top of a tendon in the forearm. This is a sure sign of tendonitis.
Another good way to tell if you have wrist flexor tendonitis is to tap your forearm. This is a "percussion test" (see image above). If tapping vigorously up and down your forearm causes pain, it's a positive sign for tendonitis.
Remember, wrist tendonitis usually is worse while you perform the hand activity that brought it on. And it normally subsides while your hand is at rest.
Listen to what your body is telling you. It’s important to pay attention to things going on around you that might be affecting your body's normal function. Only you can tell if something isn’t normal.
Pain, numbness, tingling, etc. are not normal. So be aware of it.
Above all, don’t ignore tendonitis or carpal tunnel syndrome signs for too long. They're abnormal and it’s your body’s way of telling you something isn’t right, and needs fixing. Recognizing the problem now could spell the difference between a relatively easy fix or a life of misery and chronic pain.
To treat carpal tunnel syndrome, there are many nonsurgical options to choose from. Carpal tunnel surgery usually is not necessary.
To treat wrist tendonitis, rest is the normal remedy. Avoid the activity (occupation) causing it. Then it will usually subside on its own within 2 weeks.
If you have pain, numbness or tingling in your hand or fingers, you need to know what’s causing it. Tendonitis and carpal tunnel syndrome signs are vey similar. When you know what you have for certain, you can start treatment. Treating tendonitis is far easier than carpal tunnel syndrome. But both need attention before they worsen.